Like a Bolton Out of Hell, wk of 1/27

Like a Bolton Out of Hell
This is the White House, Not a Palace


Monday, January 27
Saber-rattling conservative and lifelong Republican John Bolton's manuscript of his tell-all book has mysteriously been leaked to the public Sunday night, a day after the president's legal beagles committed themselves to a truckload of lies masquerading as a legal defense, ensuring that the week would start with a fresh discussion about GOP defectors voting for the necessity of new witnesses in the impeachment of their Chosen One. The biggest bombshell; Bolton claimed that #3 had directly ordered him in August to withhold military aid to Ukraine until Zelensky agreed to announce investigations into the Bidens, which goes to the core of the charges against #3. I guess his GOP defenders should be careful what they wish for; they asked for evidence directly linking the president to the halt on aid and they got a witness just begging to tell them that. (NYT)

Bolton's attorney says they did not leak the manuscript.  Exactly one copy was given to the White House so the NSC could vet it for any national security issues. The manuscript was delivered on 12/30/19, just 12 days after #3 was impeached.  It is unlikely that a single copy was passed amongst all the people who would be involved in the vetting process, and given how leaky this White House has been, it's hard to believe that the leak didn't come from the White House itself.  I wouldn't be surprised if #3 ordered the leak in order to discredit Bolton ahead of the publication of his book, much as AG "dis"Barr  tried to discredit Mueller weeks before his official report was released to the public.  #3 has claimed that he "never" told Bolton that military aid to Ukraine was conditioned on investigations into the Bidens. Why would he tell his hand-picked national security advisor about military aid for the security of one of our allies? (Politico, NYT)

Remember when Midnight Mitch said he was in "total coordination" with the White House on the impeachment thing? Well, maybe "total" was too strong a word.  Turns out Mitch was not informed the White House had a copy of Bolton's book, and now GOP senators are feeling blindsided about the revelations being leaked.  The Dems are calling for Bolton to be subpoenaed so he can give that critical, first-hand testimony the repubs have claimed they want to hear.  The news has so rocked the GOP that there is talk of enough defections to pass a vote to hear from witnesses. The likely suspects are Mitt Romney, Susan Collins and Lisa Murkowski; they'll need a 4th to play Bridge. (Axios, Bloomberg, NBC News, Politico, WSJ)

#3 threatens Adam Schiff with a tweet; "Shifty Adam Schiff is a CORRUPT POLITICIAN, and probably a very sick man.  he has not paid the price, yet, for what he has done to our Country!" Somebody's got his panties in a twist. (CNN, WAPO)

The associates of Rudy whom #3 claims not to know attended a small dinner with #3 and some republican donors at the trump International Hotel in April 2018 and discussed assistance to Ukraine and removing Amb. Marie Yovanovitch.  Neither the Bidens nor corruption was mentioned. Igor took video of the meeting, approximately 80 minutes worth, and shared it with Lev. The recording was on their devices when they were arrested last October as they attempted to flee the country with one-way tickets out of the country. News of the audio recording was published by ABC News. Lev and his attorney discovered a copy of the recording on his SoundCloud account and turned it over to the House Intel Committee. On the recording, #3 can be heard saying, "Get her out tomorrow. I don't care. Get her out tomorrow. Take her out. Okay? Do it."  The guy who made himself famous by saying "you're fired" suddenly forgot the words used to fire someone.  He sounds like a mob boss ordering a hit.  No wonder Yovanovitch received a panicked call one night a year later, telling her to take the next plane out of the country because her security was at risk. (ABC News, NYT, TalkingPointsMemo)

We begin the week with 50% of Americans believing the Senate should vote to convict and remove #3.  The poll was done by Faux Nooz, so we know it must be true. (Fox News)

Tuesday, January 28
More revelations from Bolton's book, The Room Where It Happened, continue to leak out.  Bolton told AG "dis" Barr last year about concerns he had over #3 granting personal favors to the leaders of Turkey and China. And Barr noticed the behavior as well, telling Bolton that he was also concerned that #3 had "created the appearance that he had undue influence" over what were supposed to be independent inquiries.  As example, Barr pointed out DOJ investigations in the Chinese telecommunications company, ZTE, and the second largest state-owned bank in Turkey, Halbank. (NYT)

The Room Where It Happened is the title of a song from the musical, Hamilton.  Here are some of the lyrics; "No one else was in the room where it happened. No one really knows how the game is played/ The art of the trade/ How the sausage gets made/ We just assume that it happens." (Mic.com)

Thanks to the Bolton book revelations, Midnight Mitch was forced to admit he does not have the votes to block impeachment witnesses. He does not have 51 votes to block witnesses; there are 53 republicans in the Senate.  Sen. Angus King (ME-I) says he wouldn't be surprised if there were 5-10 repubs who would join the Dems in voting for witnesses.  Sen. James Lankford (OK-R) has proposed giving senators the chance to read the manuscript in the SCIF, but Chuck Schumer called that "an absurd proposal." Especially since the author is prepared to testify in public. (Bloomberg, NYT)

Staging what I'm sure he thought would be a great distraction to the impeachment "hoax," #3 announced his Middle East Peace Plan with Bibi standing by his side.  Unfortunately, Bibi was indicted on corruption and fraud charges in 3 cases hours before the announcement, and dropped his request for parliamentary immunity.  #3 called his plan a "win-win" for both sides, but I'm not sure which sides those are.  The Palestinians were not consulted in the creation of the plan and rejected it prior to the announcement; they were not invited to attend.  Not a single Arab country supports the plan, which gives Israel everything and the Palestinians nothing. Why yes, we are tired of all this "winning." (NYT, LAT)

And while we were all distracted by the rest of the circus, #3's legal team concluded their circus, otherwise known as his defense.  The best part was when Pat Cipollone, the White House attorney, made the best case for calling Bolton as a witness; saying impeachment "is not a game of leaks and unsourced manuscripts." (Bloomberg, Politico, NBC News)

Put this in the "promises not kept" column; the U.S. budget deficit is projected to surpass $1 trillion in 2020 according to the Congressional Budget Office. During his campaign, #3 promised to eliminate the deficit in 8 years; so far he has increased it by almost 2/3's in under 3 years. (AP, Newsweek)

Wednesday, January 29
The impeachment trial moved to written questions from the senators.  Biggest take-away; Dershowitz  argued that #3 can't be impeached because his actions were aimed at getting re-elected, which was in the public interest, so it doesn't matter if he abused his powers or the public trust. Although to be fair, Dersh did admit his arguments were purely academic and not likely to find much agreement among his colleagues. (NBC News, Politico, NPR)

The White House has threatened to block publication of Bolton's book, claiming it contains "TOP SECRET" classified information that would harm national security.  The NSC has had the manuscript since 12/30/19, and 2 days after the manuscript is leaked, leading to calls for Bolton to testify, the NSC suddenly issues a letter that the manuscript must not be published.  Fine; we didn't want to buy his book anyway.  Just let Bolton testify.  Or hold a press conference in prime time. (Axios, NBC News)

A witness who hopes to be called to testify, Rudy Giuliani, claims he "never, ever" discussed Ukraine military aid with #3. But he surely discussed something about Ukraine with #3 before going there to meet with former, disgraced Ukrainian officials.  Spill, Rudy. (CBS News)

Among the possible votes for further impeachment witnesses, there are possible Dem votes for acquittal. Joe Minchin, Doug Jones and Kirsten Sinema (the latter 2 who were helped over the finish line in their states by an outpouring of Dem support) say they are not yet convinced to vote for removal from office. Said Manchin, "I know it's hard to believe that." Buddy, you have no idea. Manchin also believes that Hunter Biden is a relevant witness, because it would be an opportunity to clear his name.  Where do I start? First, a trial is NOT the place a WITNESS goes to clear his name. Second, putting a witness on the stand to attempt to prove his guilt is a VIOLATION OF DUE PROCESS." The GOP could have called for an investigation into Hunter Biden years ago; and finding enough relevant evidence to hold a trial, the younger Biden could have secured legal counsel and had his day in court. But I suspect the GOP knows there's no there there with either of the Bidens. They get far more mileage out of meritless accusations and unfounded allegations.  If you repeat them often enough, people will start to believe it.  (Politico, Axios)

Conflict of interest: #3's attorneys Ken Starr and Robert Ray gave thousands to Midnight Mitch last year.  Gives a whole new meaning to Mitch's declaration to be working "in total coordination with the White House." (Slate)

Another day, another distraction.  This time to sign the revised NAFTA, dubbed the USMCA.  Never one to miss an opportunity to be petty, #3 made sure to exclude the Dems who helped the bill to pass, joking that he needs senators' votes for an acquittal in his impeachment trial.  The USMCA still needs to be ratified by Canada, so it's not a done deal yet. (Bloomberg, CNN, Politico)

Thursday, January 30
Any hope of GOP defectors willing to vote to see evidence evaporated today as midnight Mitch indicated he had the votes to block the Dem motion to consider new witnesses and documents.  Now there is concern that some Dems, whose seats are considered endangered in their home states, may break ranks with the Dems and vote with the GOP; Kyrsten Sinema (AZ), Joe Manchin (WVA), and Doug Jones (AL)

Bolton's attorney says that his client's book does not contain classified material, contrary to the White House claim that the book contains "significant amounts" of classified material.  A significant charge made in the book is generating fear in the White House: Bolton says #3 told him in August that he was tying Ukranian investigations into the Bidens to releasing foreign aid. But #3 himself says that Bolton is lying, so how could lies amount to classified material? If it's not true, it's not classified. The book is going to come out anyway. (WAPO)

Lev Parnas has released a new video recording that shows him and Igor Fruman and some GOP donors at the April 2018 dinner in which the firing of Marie Yovanovitch was discussed.  In attendance were former Rep. Pete Sessions (already subpoenaed in the Parnas/Fruman case) and Ronna McDaniel, the RNC chair (also a niece of Mittens Romney).  So much for #3's claims that he didn't know Lev or Igor, or that he didn't know who Yovanovitch was. (AP, PBS, CNN)

On the same day that the DOJ argued in Federal court that a remedy for an executive branch defying a congressional subpoena was impeachment, #3's legal team argued the exact opposite. Chief Justice Roberts got off his thumbs long enough to refuse to read Rand Paul's question because he did not want to reveal the name of the whistleblower.  But he promptly sat back down on this thumbs and did not enforce the rules when Paul left the Senate in a huff to conduct a news conference in which he revealed the whistleblower's name (Politico, CNN)

A section of #3's new border wall in CA fell over during winds gusts (up to 37 mph!) and landed on the Mexican side of the border.  And no, Mexico is still not going to pay for that wall. (CNN)

E. Jean Carroll, who accused #3 of raping her in a NYC department store dressing room in the 1990's, has asked for a sample of his DNA.  Because she saved her dress.  HER DRESS.  Once again, it comes down to a woman and her dress. Carroll filed a defamation suit against #3 in November after he called her a liar.  Hope he gets what's coming to him. (AP)

Friday, January 31
The day of the vote has arrived and we can finally count the number of GOP defectors on 2 fingers: Mitt Romney, who had already indicated how he was going to vote days ago, and Susan Collins, who apparently did the political calculus and determined throwing her lot in with the Dems might offer some protection in her looming political defeat this fall.  The Dems remained united. Last night you could see midnight Mitch working hard on Lisa Murkowski, pointing to a list on a piece of paper and counting on his fingers.  Murkowski left the trial last night in a bad mood, saying she was frustrated with "both sides." Oh, not that both sides argument again. Today she revealed that because she thought the House had rushed the process and turned in a flawed product (although she did not identify what the flaws were), she was voting against new witnesses & evidence.  Of course.  Now that the Senate had the chance to take their time and fix the flaws... it was time to rush to a judgement and ignore any further evidence. Last night Lamar Alexander announced he would be voting against the Dem resolution, and then beat a hasty retreat so he wouldn't have to answer any questions.  In a statement, he said that the Dems had proved their case and he didn't need to see any more evidence to be convinced.  How nice of him to make that decision for those who maybe did need to see more evidence.  He also said that the president's actions were inappropriate, but that wasn't enough to remove him from office. Ben Sasse said Alexander spoke for him and an unspecified number of other GOP senators.  Let me stop here and summarize: a number of GOP senators believe that #3 is guilty as charged and that's why they don't need to see more evidence.  And then there's Marco Rubio, who had this to say, "Just because actions meet a standard of impeachment does not mean it is in the best interest of the country to remove a president from office." Actually, yes.  Yes it does.  It's called the rule of law.  (Politico, NBC News, Reuters, NPR, CNN, The Hill)

Many people are in despair today, calling this the day that Democracy died.  Just stop it right now.  Our democracy has taken a hit; the GOP senators did not do their duty and #3 will continue his criminal ways.  Are you really surprised? Don't be.  Are you mad? You should be. Democracy is not a spectator sport.  If you feel faint of heart, have some chocolate. Time to put your steel toe boots on.  We have voters to register, House seats to defend and Senate seats to flip.  We will soon have a Dem nominee for president to rally around.  #3 lost the popular vote in 2016.  Only 26% of registered voters voted for him.  All we need to do is turn out and vote.  When Dems vote Dems win.

Nancy Pelosi called the senators who voted against witnesses, "accomplices to the president's cover-up." Adam Schiff warned, "The facts will come out." Former white house chief of staff John Kelly said he considers the Senate impeachment trial "a job only half done" without witnesses.  Looks like it may be up to Bolton and Parnas to exercise their first amendment right of free speech and reveal those facts to finish the job. (Politico, NBC News, WSJ, Bloomberg, Axios)

It had been reported earlier that Mitch had promised #3 the trial would be over before the Super Bowl on Sunday, but that appears not to be the case.  The Senate will resume on Monday for 4 hours of closing arguments.  Tuesday will be devoted to final comments on the floor of the Senate.  #3 will give his SOTU with the final vote still hanging over his head, but everyone expects him to gloat and lie and mumble his way through it.  The final vote will be next Wednesday, where the Senate is widely expected to acquit him.  But he'll always be #3, the third US president to be impeached.

A new drip and drab from Bolton's manuscript has emerged.  #3 directed Bolton back in May 2019 to help pressure Ukraine to turn over damaging information on his political rival.  In his book, Bolton claims that #3 told him to call Zelensky, elected just the month before, and press him to meet with Rudy to discuss the investigations.  Bolton says he did not follow through.  Also at the meeting were Mick Mulvaney and Pat Cipollone.  That would explain why the House Impeachment managers sent a letter to Cipollone prior to the start of the trial that he might be a material witness.  Now we know why that letter was sent, and likely that the House managers had other information implicating Cipollone, who has a conflict of interest in representing his client.  The calls for Cipollone to be disbarred have already begun.  (NYT)

Lev does not seem to be taking the Senate vote today sitting down.  His lawyer has sent a letter to midnight Mitch outlining all the evidence Lev is prepared to testify to if only Mitch would allow him to be called as a witness.  His testimony would be based on "personal knowledge, corroborated by physical evidence, including text messages, phone records, documentary evidence and travel records." Parnas is also prepared to name names of those involved in the Ukraine scandal: Mike Pence, Bill Barr, Lindsey Graham, Rick Perry, Devin Nunes, Derek Harvey (Nunes' aide), John Solomon (a right-wing journalist), and #3's attorneys, Joe diGenova and Victoria Toensing, and America First (a pro-trump super PAC).  It was a deal midnight Mitch refused to consider, but there are sure to be any number of news outlets willing to give Lev and exclusive.  As Schiff said, the facts will come out.  (NBC News)

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Dow of Donald wk of 2/5

Oops, Pardon Me (No Pun Intended) wk of 7/24

And She Persisted wk of 5/8/17